Best Shampoo for Your Hair? Liquid Shampoo vs. Solid Shampoo

May 30, 2024 5 min read

smile Infographic of liquid Vs solid shampoos

Discover Which Type of Shampoo Offers More Benefits for Both You and the Environment

In the UK, approximately 520 million shampoo bottles are discarded every year. This startling figure underscores the significant environmental impact of traditional liquid shampoos, packaged in plastic bottles that contribute heavily to waste. But with the rise of solid shampoo bars, there is hope for more sustainable hair care options that don't compromise on quality. Solid bars not only help reduce plastic waste but also often contain more concentrated formulas, meaning you get more washes for your money - and with fewer environmental consequences.

But how do solid shampoo bars stack up against their liquid counterparts in terms of hair care? Let’s dive into the details and compare the two, so you can make an informed decision about what’s best for your hair and the planet.

Solid Shampoo vs. Liquid Shampoo: Environmental Impact

Liquid shampoos are often packaged in plastic bottles that contribute to the enormous problem of single-use plastic waste. Solid shampoo bars, however, typically come in minimal or zero-waste packaging, such as recyclable cardboard or reusable tins. Switching to solid shampoo could make a substantial difference in reducing plastic waste.

Solid shampoo bars are also more concentrated than liquid shampoos. This means less product is needed per wash, which can result in fewer emissions from transportation due to the smaller size and weight of the product. A study revealed that switching from liquid to solid shampoo could cut packaging waste by up to 80%.

Solid Shampoo vs. Liquid Shampoo

Why Is pH Balance Important?

When choosing a shampoo, pH balance plays a key role in hair health. Hair and scalp have a natural pH of 4.5 to 5.5, and using products that are too alkaline (like soap-based bars) can damage the hair's cuticle, making it dry and frizzy.

Many soap-based shampoo bars have a high pH due to the saponification process, making them less ideal for hair care. In contrast, well-formulated solid shampoo bars are designed to be pH-balanced, offering gentle cleansing without disrupting the scalp’s natural balance. This is an important consideration when choosing a shampoo, whether it’s solid or liquid.

Shampoo Comparison: Liquid vs. Solid Shampoo

Criteria Liquid Shampoo Solid Shampoo
Packaging Plastic bottles (often single-use) Zero-waste or minimal packaging (paper, tins) 
Environmental Impact High due to plastic waste Low - significantly reduces plastic consumption
Water Content Contains up to 80% water Concentrated, typically contains little to no water
Portability Bulky, risk of spills Compact, ideal for travel, no risk of leaks
Product Longevity  Generally used up quickly due to diluted formula Lasts longer—more washes per bar
pH Balance Typically pH-balanced Needs to be checked—choose pH-balanced options
Cleansing Ingredients Can include sulfates and chemicals Often uses gentle, natural surfactants
Price Can be cheaper upfront but used up quickly Lasts longer and is more economical in the long run
Effectiveness for Hair Health Effective for cleansing, but may contain harsh chemicals Effective with fewer ingredients, good for sensitive scalps

 

 Why Solid Shampoo Bars Are Trending

The increasing popularity of solid shampoo bars can be attributed to several key factors:

  1. Environmental Awareness: With the rise of zero-waste and eco-friendly living, many consumers are seeking sustainable alternatives to traditional liquid shampoos. Solid shampoo bars are appealing due to their minimal packaging and lower carbon footprint .

  2. Longer-Lasting: A single shampoo bar can outlast two to three bottles of liquid shampoo. Because they are more concentrated, less product is required per use, making them more cost-effective in the long term.

  3. Portability: Shampoo bars are compact and easy to carry, making them perfect for travel. They’re lightweight, and there’s no risk of spillage - perfect for avoiding the dreaded shampoo explosion in your luggage.

  4. Healthier Ingredients: Many solid shampoo bars are formulated with natural, gentle ingredients that are free from sulfates and harsh chemicals. This makes them a better option for people with sensitive scalps or those looking to avoid synthetic additives .

  5. Customisable for Hair Types: With the growing demand, solid shampoo bars are now available for all hair types, from curly to oily, and are designed to address specific hair concerns like dryness, dandruff, or frizz. These bars often incorporate nourishing ingredients like natural oils, shea butter, and herbal extracts, leaving hair feeling soft and clean.

    Find the right shampoo for your hair type with our handy guide

Why Liquid Shampoos Still Dominate

Despite the advantages of solid shampoo bars, liquid shampoos still dominate the market for a few reasons:

  • Familiarity: Most people are accustomed to liquid shampoo and may feel hesitant about switching to a solid bar. Liquid shampoo is perceived as easier to use and more convenient, especially for those with specific hair care routines.

  • Variety: Liquid shampoos offer a wider range of specialised products, from medicated shampoos to treatments for very specific hair conditions. While solid shampoo bars are catching up, liquid shampoos still offer more options.

Sustainability: Making the Switch to Solid Shampoo

Making the switch to solid shampoo isn’t just about hair care - it’s also a conscious choice to reduce your environmental impact. With 520 million shampoo bottles discarded annually in the UK alone (Source: Packaging company, DS Smith), the move towards solid bars can make a real difference.

If even a fraction of the population switched to solid shampoo bars, it would result in significant reductions in plastic waste. Not only do solid bars require less packaging, but they are also lighter and take up less space, reducing the environmental cost of transportation.

The demand for eco-friendly hair care is on the rise, and it’s easy to see why. With benefits for both your hair and the planet, solid shampoo bars represent a positive step towards more sustainable living.

lady with healthy hair

Final Thoughts: Which Shampoo Is Best for Your Hair?

Both liquid and solid shampoos have their pros and cons, but for those looking to minimise environmental impact, solid shampoo bars offer clear advantages. As long as you choose a high-quality, pH-balanced shampoo bar that suits your hair type, you can expect great results without compromising on performance.

If you’ve had a poor experience with a shampoo bar in the past, don’t be discouraged. It’s likely that the bar you used wasn’t a well-formulated product. Quality matters - choose wisely, and you’ll enjoy cleaner, healthier hair for longer.

To make the switch, check out the award-winning natural shampoo bars and conditioner bars from The Solid Bar Company. Use discount code THANK YOU at checkout to get 10% off your order today! 

(Please note: this post has been updated for 2024)

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.